Nearly One in Four Auto Claims Is Now a Total Loss. Here’s What That Means for Colorado Drivers.

A record 23.1% of auto insurance claims are now ending as total losses, according to CCC Intelligent Solutions’ Crash Course 2026 report. On non-comprehensive claims, the figure is even higher: 23.9%.

That is not a rounding error. It is a structural shift. More cars are being written off, fewer are going back to collision shops, and more Colorado drivers are being handed a check and told the story is over.

At BP Auto Appraisals, that is the moment our phone usually rings.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

The math that is writing cars off

Insurers do not total a vehicle because it “looks bad.” They total it when the projected cost to repair approaches or exceeds a percentage of the car’s actual cash value (ACV) — the pre-loss market value they assign to it.

Three forces are pushing more files across that line.

Repair costs have caught up to older cars. The average total cost of repair on a repairable claim is now about $4,818. On vehicles six years old or newer, it is $5,721. Cameras, radar, ultrasonic sensors, and OEM-required ADAS calibrations have turned what used to be a bumper and a blend into a four-figure diagnostic event. A hit that would have been a straightforward repair in 2018 now carries aiming procedures, programming, and documentation that did not exist on the estimate a decade ago.

The fleet is older, so ACVs are thinner. The average light vehicle on U.S. roads is 12.8 years old. There are roughly 12 million fewer vehicles six years old or newer in operation than there were in 2020. Vehicles in the 7–12-year band now make up 41% of total-loss valuations, up from 33.4% in 2020. An older car with a modest ACV does not have to be destroyed to be totaled. It only has to be expensive to put back together.

Driveable cars are being totaled. This is the piece most owners do not expect. The share of driveable vehicles flagged as total losses is 3.5 points higher than it was in 2021. You can still start it, drive it home, and park it in the driveway — and the carrier will still call it a total. Age, parts cost, and calibration requirements are doing the work that frame damage used to do.

On vehicles 13 years and older, CCC now flags 45.3% of claims as total losses.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

The claims that never show up

There is a second, quieter shift underneath the total-loss number.

26% of consumers now carry a $1,000+ deductible, up 3.5 points in a single year. Smaller first-party claims — the dent, the parking-lot bumper, the cracked cover — are increasingly paid out of pocket or not repaired at all. Repairable appraisals of $2,000 or less have fallen from 41.5% of the mix in 2019 to 25.5% by mid-2025. Repairable claim volume dropped 9.7% last year.

The insurance file that remains is not the old mix of easy and hard. It is concentrated severity: more totals, more ADAS, more supplements, more argument over value.

That is why collision shops are reporting shorter backlogs and slower intake even as the cars that do arrive take longer and cost more. It is also why a growing share of owners are being told “it’s a total” on vehicles they expected to fix.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

What this means if you are the one holding the keys

A higher total-loss rate is not automatically a problem for the owner. A fair total-loss settlement can be the right outcome. The problem is how that number is built.

ACV is not a Kelly Blue Book screenshot. It is a supported opinion of what your vehicle would have sold for, in your market, the day before the loss — options, mileage, condition, service history, and local demand included. A national valuation tool that misses a Colorado-specific package, a recent overhaul, or a tight local market for that trim will land low. A low ACV is how a borderline repair becomes a total, and how a legitimate total becomes a short check.

Salvage value is not a throwaway line. On many files the owner is offered ACV minus deductible minus retained salvage. If salvage is overstated, the net to you shrinks. If you want to keep the car, that number matters as much as the ACV itself.

Repairable does not mean “made whole.” On the cars that are repaired, ADAS calibrations appeared on 28.3% of repairable estimates in 2025 — a 30% jump in a year — and independent shop data suggests closer to 60% of vehicles on the floor actually need some form of calibration. Missed or incomplete calibrations, aftermarket assemblies, and visible repair history are exactly why diminished value claims exist. The car may be safe and operational. The market will still discount it.

Do not confuse a first offer with a final number. The first valuation is an opening position. Colorado policies typically contain an appraisal clause. That clause lets you hire an independent appraiser, the carrier appoints theirs, and if the two cannot agree, an umpire is selected. It is a contractual right, not a lawsuit.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

What we tell clients in the Denver metro

From Arvada, we see the same national pattern on local files: more driveable totals, more 8- to 14-year-old daily drivers crossing the threshold because of sensor and structural cost, and more first offers that do not survive a proper comparable-sales analysis.

If your carrier has totaled the vehicle, or you suspect they are about to:

1. Do not sign a release or transfer the title until you understand the ACV, the salvage deduction, and the taxes/fees the policy actually owes.

2. Ask for the valuation report — every comparable, every condition adjustment, every option they did or did not credit.

3. Photograph the vehicle thoroughly, including options, maintenance records, tires, and unmodified condition. Pre-loss evidence disappears fast once the car is moved to salvage.

4. Get an independent appraisal before you accept the number. A USPAP-compliant report is what the appraisal clause, an umpire, and — if it ever goes that far — a court will actually weigh.

5. If the car is being repaired, keep every invoice, scan, and calibration printout. That file is the foundation of a diminished-value claim later.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

For shop owners reading this

We work the other side of many of the same files. The volume drop is real. The remaining work is heavier: diagnostics, structural teardown, OEM procedures, and documentation. Shops that write complete scan-and-calibration lines, charge for setup and dynamic road tests, and stop treating admin and storage as goodwill will outlast shops still staffed for 2019 bumper jobs.

Missed post-repair calibrations are not just a lost line. They are a liability. Industry estimates put roughly half of U.S. shops short on required ADAS procedures. That gap shows up later — in comebacks, in attorney letters, and in the diminished-value files that land on our desk.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Nearly one in four claims is now a total loss. That does not mean one in four owners is being paid fairly.

If you have a total-loss offer, a disputed ACV, or a repaired vehicle that is worth less than it was the morning of the accident, that is the work we do.

BP Auto Appraisals Independent vehicle appraisals — total loss, diminished value, insurance disputes, pre-purchase, classic and collector Arvada & Denver Metro · Nationwide by arrangement (720) 295-0108 · bpautoappraisals.com

Appraisals prepared in conformity with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP).